Does Closing Fantasy VII Remake’s bizarro ending work?

The Closing Fantasy VII remake does more than retell a familiar story from a standard roleplaying sport. At the same time as you happen to’re planning to play it, you shouldn’t read any additional. But whenever you happen to’ve finished the last chapter, you’ll know that its ending diverges somewhat sharply from the fashioned story — no longer handiest altering the game’s canon but turning the existence of canon steady into a do aside point. It’s ambitious, confusing, and extremely weird, and here at The Verge, reactions comprise varied deal.

How efficient was Closing Fantasy VII Remake’s mountainous sage swing? How well does it work for inexperienced persons versus longtime followers of the sequence? And since the remake handiest covers the fundamental portion of the fashioned sport, how well does it do aside up future installments?

Closing warning: spoilers for Closing Fantasy VII Remake content.

Andrew Webster, games editor: The article that struck me most about the ending — which I battle to in actuality represent — is how unexpected it was. For many of FFVIIR’s runtime, it’s a somewhat mature remake; it expands on the fashioned in essential ways, alternatively it in most cases tells the identical story, hitting the identical main do aside parts. The contemporary sport handiest covers the Midgar portion, which was in actuality the outlet from the fashioned.

I had expected that subsequent episodes would enact the identical, exploring main sections of FF7 with added issue. Now, I don’t know what to wait for. The game’s ending suggests an fully contemporary route for the story, one where the events of the fashioned are malleable, and destiny isn’t preordained but reasonably one thing that may perhaps well even simply even be altered. I started taking half in for a dose of nostalgia — but now, I comprise to know how issues will if fact be told be varied transferring forward.

Prick Statt, files editor: Given the infamously convoluted do aside of the fashioned FFVII, I used to be somewhat obvious of two issues going into the remake: the game couldn’t perhaps discontinue with Cloud and his ragtag crew steady leaving Midgar earlier than the credits roll. And I used to be obvious they would comprise to originate weaving in some aspects of the Sephiroth storyline earlier if the game truly was going to be a 30- to forty-hour stir in what is realistically handiest a diminutive allotment of the final story.

The game delivered on both parts simultaneously, and after ruminating on the ending for somewhat, I take into myth myself in the official-different universe / timeline camp. I cherished having an memoir closing battle, despite the indisputable truth that it looked out of left self-discipline. I’m for my half no longer too warm on the premise that the stakes was so high so with out word, because it feels esteem it may perhaps well permanently alter your whole characters’ attitudes in the occasion that they know from the onset that that is all about saving the realm from a individual they barely know, in its do aside of slowly accepting such a friendly accountability as more of the final do aside is printed.

But atmospherically, it was very Closing Fantasy, and I will forgive Nomura and crew for delivering somewhat of Advent Teenagers-inspired fan carrier when the game needed it most.

The do aside this remake sequence goes from here is anyone’s bet, and I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t a exiguous bit panicked that section two may perhaps well even steady be a rushed supreme hits compilation or some “it was steady a Sephiroth-brought on dream in the Lifestream” nonsense. No longer like quite a bit of the diehard “make it a scene-by-scene remake” crowd that’s very vocal on the ranking agreeable now, I’m no longer as alive to that they’re going to alternate the whole lot and completely rewrite the script. But it’d be a exact shame to let your whole friendly work into making these characters truly feel so out of the ordinary more alive than they did 25 years ago move to waste by relying too out of the ordinary on the overly ambitious twisty aspects we’re now contending with.

Michael Moore, critiques coordinator: I feel what I found frustrating about the ending is it’s laborious to recount what breaking from the fashioned events methodology from here on out. They successfully showed for the length of the comfort of the game that they had been tantalizing to hit main moments in the identical or identical ways, but add contemporary self-discipline cloth to support give a accumulate to the storytelling and supplies characters more development when put next with the fashioned.

So that you just can beat gamers over the pinnacle with how varied issues may perhaps well even simply be going forward feels esteem an absence of self belief what got here earlier than where they’d successfully shown gamers how issues had been going to deviate from the fashioned FFVII. That, or what they’re making an attempt to acquire across is how varied issues will likely be from here on out, which is unknowable at this point with out one thing to move on.

Kevin Nguyen, parts editor: I didn’t comprise the ending contaminated for me, but along the methodology, I saved getting texts from pals who’d finished to let me know when they bought there. They wanted to discuss about, and I notion I used to be in for a mountainous twist or existing. After ending a considerably slack battle with Sephiroth and watching a considerably satisfying CG montage, I hit the credits and puzzled what exactly I’d overlooked. There’s the present of Zack aloof being alive, which supposed… what exactly?

It turns out, it doesn’t indicate out of the ordinary at all. Sure, the Whispers are dreary, which now methodology destiny isn’t any longer predetermined. What it methodology to followers is that the remake has now written in a do aside machine that enables it to deviate from the fashioned.

Right here is deeply odd to me! Why enact the makers of the Closing Fantasy VII Remake comprise to present themselves permission to alternate up the story? In fact, let me rephrase that: why does your whole do aside of the game comprise to result in a second that announces “you is also taking half in a remake”? Wait, let me strive that yet yet any other time: hhrrngghh!!! [inexperienced flashback sound; Sephiroth looks to recount me “did you understand remakes may perhaps well even furthermore be varied than the fashioned?”]

All in all, I had a ball blasting through 30-some hours of a exiguous bit elevated horned up hack ‘n sever. Mechanically, the game is leaps and bounds greater than the fashioned; I steady wish the writing had taken even a step forward.

Sam Byford, Asia editor: Main as a lot as free up, I notion the methodology that Sq. Enix actually titled this sport “Closing Fantasy VII Remake” was goofy fan carrier. After ending it, despite the indisputable truth that, the title makes out of the ordinary more sense. What I want and inquire of out of Closing Fantasy games is unparalleled do aside twists, and it doesn’t acquire out of the ordinary more moderen than the revelation that Closing Fantasy VII Remake is never any longer a straight remake of Closing Fantasy VII, but an extremely-meta alternate-universe model that exists mainly to meditate on the notion that of remaking Closing Fantasy VII.

The twist is esteem an inversion of Steel Equipment Solid 2, which, upon free up, printed itself to be as out of the ordinary a subversive, postmodern remix of the fashioned as a straight sequel, with a previously unannounced protagonist taking half in through mysteriously familiar events. I didn’t think it may perhaps well be imaginable to pull one thing esteem that off again in on the present time’s clockwork video sport hype cycle, but I esteem that Sq. Enix went for it.

Whether or not they’ll stick the touchdown is one other topic fully. It’s laborious to name this a friendly notion with out taking half in the next episode of the game, and who knows when that’ll masks up. But the ending makes me some distance more mad for it than I would comprise been in the occasion that they’d performed it straight. I mainly truly enjoyed what Closing Fantasy VII Remake did with its characters, and I’m making an attempt ahead to spending more time with them with out arresting their fates upfront.

The ending gets a cautious thumbs-up from me for now. But I furthermore think Tetsuya Nomura potentially steady wanted an excuse to contrive a Sephiroth boss battle do aside to “One Winged Angel” on the discontinue of what is in actuality a remake of the fundamental 10 percent of Closing Fantasy VII, so. Let’s steady express I’m attracted to what comes subsequent with out essentially making an attempt ahead to it to be trusty and even coherent.

Megan Farokhmanesh, reporter: It is with the utmost humility and beauty that I must permit you to know all that Closing Fantasy VII Remake is a sport made completely for me and nobody else. I performed the fashioned as a younger pre-teen, fed on its fanfic for years, and gradually allowed my brain to melt steady into a puddle of jelly that spells out “I <3 Cloud Strife.”

(I’m kidding. Am I kidding? When Prick known as the do aside convoluted, I had the fully deranged gut response of “um excuse me what don’t you be taught about a magical mature of us connected to a myth power circulation that fuels the planet itself, yet may perhaps well even furthermore be commandeered by a guy with gravity-defying bangs and mommy considerations on an Oedipal degree? Makes supreme sense to me.” I’m insupportable!)

The response we’re all having — a combine between “is this allowed?” and “enact I esteem it?” — speaks to the extremely overblown, overly treasured canonization of cherished games. The fates of Closing Fantasy VII’s solid is so do aside in my brain that the premise Aerith may perhaps well even continue to exist, as an instance, turns me steady into a sputtering fool. “But if she lives, that changes the very fabric of the game. How can any of the story exist with out her loss of life?” — as despite the indisputable truth that any writer is never any longer allowed to dream up some contemporary, attention-grabbing route. That the game’s creators felt the comprise to battle so laborious and weave the very notion of alternate in as metatextual flavor feels esteem they’re preemptively heading off followers esteem me: know-it-alls who would argue about what the game needs to be on myth of we’ve spent the last two decades building it up in our heads.

That’s a extremely long-winded lead-as a lot as claim that even supposing I feel FFVIIR’s ending truly flies off the rails in additional ways than one, I’m in. I’m no longer obvious Zack is truly aloof alive or if one thing will truly be varied. I’ve fantasized about future episodes giving you a preference to both continue along the game’s fashioned route or explore a brand contemporary story, the last methodology for followers to deem what truly issues more: canon or creativity. But most of all, I esteem a exact story troll. Correct rip the partitions down round me.

Adi Robertson, senior reporter: These earlier few responses truly crystallize my ambivalence. On paper, I esteem Closing Fantasy VII Remake doing an irreverent high-notion metatextual model of the normal “now we comprise to move abolish God” do aside where God is the author of Closing Fantasy VII. It’s the Grant Morrison Animal Man of JRPGs!

On the purely textual degree, despite the indisputable truth that, the ending doesn’t enact one thing. The characters know they’ve, esteem… murdered predestination. But as Prick says, that battle comes out of left self-discipline, and there’s no exact sense of why it issues previous avoiding some amorphously unpleasant match. It ignores quite a bit of more attention-grabbing story threads, esteem Cloud’s origins (he isn’t a SOLDIER?), Sephiroth’s previous, and one thing setting up who Zack is and why I’m in a position to also simply aloof care.

I know how the fashioned sport answers these questions, and the remake may perhaps well even comprise frail them to existing why the canon changes are compelling, in its do aside of steady declaring that they exist. As it stands, I truly feel esteem it supplies revelations for folk who esteem talking about Closing Fantasy VII but no satisfying trends in the steady sage.

I handiest performed (section of) the fashioned sport last 300 and sixty five days, despite the indisputable truth that, so I’m uncommon how of us’s relationship with Closing Fantasy VII fashioned their reactions. How does the ending work whenever you happen to’re no longer a mountainous fan, as an instance? Does it recontextualize the fashioned sport whenever you happen to is also?

Sam: I’m no longer a mountainous Closing Fantasy VII fan. The one I even comprise essentially the most nostalgia for is VIII, which is… much less popular overall. I know the mountainous strokes of the VII story, and I performed throughout the Midgar portion of the game on Switch last 300 and sixty five days as homework, but that mainly steady served to present me an even bigger appreciation of Remake’s extremely trusty rearranged soundtrack.

I feel I could perhaps well well be in the supreme house to love this ending. I’m no longer shut enough to the story to be all that attracted to a straight retelling, but I’m familiar enough for the twist to resonate and for me to marvel what occurs subsequent. I used to be making an attempt ahead to Remake steady to be VII’s Midgar with additional padding — and, to be clear, that’s exactly what it is for roughly 95 percent of its runtime — but I’m no longer obvious that device would comprise held my attention over who-knows-how-many episodes. Now, despite the indisputable truth that, I’m no longer much less than on board for the next one.

Kevin: Sam, I’m unquestionably coming from the identical do aside as you, but the ending left me feeling more essentially based on Adi. The Remake had a dozen gratuitous accept quests. You’d think regarded as one of them may perhaps well even comprise alive to rummaging round a slum to search out an reasonably priced backstory for Zack in its do aside of, esteem, three cats.

Michael: I’m no longer the supreme FFVII fan, alternatively it has been my popular Closing Fantasy sport until no longer too long ago. (I aloof dangle the fashioned PS1 copy I purchased on beginning day.) And almost certainly on myth of I didn’t play FFVIIR and in its do aside watched my roommate (who’s a out of the ordinary out of the ordinary bigger fan) play in its do aside I found that, at a clear point, I ended pondering of the remake as FFVII and in its do aside its dangle sport.

While it was aloof hitting moments from the fashioned, there is steady so out of the ordinary added into it that it is one thing else fully, which makes it truly feel much less esteem a retelling of the fashioned sport and more esteem what the Rebuild of Evangelion movies are to the fashioned Neon Genesis Evangelion anime sequence. While the fundamental movie remains a somewhat devoted remake of the early episodes of the masks, the movie’s ending and the next motion footage launch to deviate deal from what the sequence did. Changing events and introducing completely contemporary characters, making it clear that these motion footage aren’t a retelling of the sequence but one thing else contemporary fully.

The ending feels esteem this would be the mannequin for the games going forward, and truly, I’m if fact be told out of the ordinary more uncommon about what that may perhaps well even indicate then if it was steady straight retelling the fashioned sport.

Megan: There’s one thing truly special to me, the handiest Actual Gamer on workers, about seeing how the remake brings FFVII’s world alive. I replayed the fashioned about a months earlier than Remake got here out, and now, what I as soon as cherished earnestly as its dangle sport feels exiguous more than a bare-bones elaborate. Listed below are the beats, and here’s a classic glance on the realm. I spent quite a bit of time staring up — on the plate, on the empty sky, at a extremely tall building here and there. The filler aggravated me, but quite a bit of the time, I felt giddy operating round this world I more or much less knew. That’s selection of how I truly feel about your whole sport. It steady feels mountainous and loopy and thrilling to search out one thing contemporary on this very frail story.

Adi: We’re all talking across the elephant (chocobo? tonberry? hell house?) in the room: will the saga if fact be told acquire performed? Given how long this sport took and the device large Closing Fantasy VII is, I’m no longer convinced that may happen. Does the ending aloof stand on its dangle if it doesn’t?

Megan: Possibly I’ve steady watched and cherished too many canceled TV reveals, but I feel this ending may perhaps well even stand on its dangle, if you performed the fashioned sport and comprehend it well. Hear me out: Remake constructed out the realm, it brought in Sephiroth early, it — okay, well, it didn’t truly masks quite a bit on its dangle. But it reexamined enough of the fashioned to present followers an expanded check up on of that world. I’m no longer asserting I’d esteem it if the sequence was by no methodology performed. But I feel there is enough of a aggregate of the frail sport and this contemporary, unknown notion to make it an open-ended… ending. Let the fanfic communities move wild.

Sam: Yeah, fully no longer. This ending handiest works in the occasion that they content through with a smooth address the storyline, but I even comprise a feeling they’ll land on one thing esteem “omg Aerith lives.” While I don’t doubt that the saga will likely be performed at last, I’m out of the ordinary more skeptical of how they move about it. For now, despite the indisputable truth that, no longer much less than the possibility exists that it may perhaps well be cool, and I’m here for the dawdle. In potentially several years.

Michael: I feel it may perhaps well take a supernova destroying Sq. for them to no longer construct this sequence.

Prick: The handiest reasonably priced methodology for it to total — and I feel it has to comprise a correct conclusion — is that the sequence introduces your whole familiar story beats and ends as standard, but with the characters’ files that they’re acting out a script and, in some cases, deviating from it where the writers watch match.

I’m in a position to’t watch them sparing Aerith or steady forgoing a conclusion fully, but I’m in a position to also watch a issue wherein she makes the preference herself arresting it may perhaps well do her pals and the planet. Or almost certainly there’s a timeline where she and Zack both reside. Issues esteem that may perhaps well even spice up the fashioned do aside whereas aloof conserving the whole lot in check. God support the gamers who haven’t performed the fashioned, despite the indisputable truth that, on myth of on occasion any of that is ideal even to essentially the most diehard FFVII fan.

Megan: I aloof think Prick is atrocious. What’s so laborious to realise about the fashioned story, you guys!